 |
| Comparison facilities provided to indian army and Indian paramilitary forces, what are the similarity and differences |
The Indian Army and Indian Paramilitary Forces (such as BSF, CRPF, ITBP, CISF, and SSB) are vital for national security but differ in their operational roles and the facilities provided to their personnel. Below is a comparison of the facilities, highlighting similarities and differences:
Comparison of Facilities
| Aspect | Indian Army | Indian Paramilitary Forces | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Accommodation | Permanent housing, barracks, and transit facilities. | Similar accommodation provided, often near border areas. | Army infrastructure is typically more developed due to larger budgets and strategic needs. |
| Medical Facilities | Access to military hospitals (MH) and armed forces specialists. | Central Government Health Scheme (CGHS) and force-run hospitals. | Army hospitals are more advanced due to the critical nature of defense roles. |
| Education for Children | Army Public Schools (APS) and subsidized schooling. | Kendriya Vidyalayas (KVs) and subsidized education. | Both offer quality education, though the Army has its dedicated school network. |
| Canteen (CSD) | Comprehensive CSD facilities for subsidized goods. | Limited CSD facilities compared to the Army. | The Army enjoys wider access and discounts due to CSD's larger network. |
| Leave and Holidays | Generous leave policies, including special leave for operations. | Similar leave policies, but may vary by force and duty location. | Both prioritize personnel welfare but adapt policies based on operational demands. |
| Retirement and Pension | Higher pensions under One Rank One Pension (OROP). | National Pension Scheme (NPS) for recruits post-2004. | Army pensions are generally better due to OROP. |
| Family Welfare | Welfare organizations for families, including AWES (Army Welfare Education Society). | Family welfare schemes are available but more limited. | Army programs are more extensive. |
| Transport Facilities | Free or subsidized railway and air travel. | Similar free travel facilities, mostly for duty purposes. | Both enjoy travel concessions, but the Army may have more flexibility. |
| Insurance Coverage | High-risk insurance policies, including death and disability coverage. | Similar insurance coverage but with lower premiums. | The Army offers higher coverage due to the nature of its high-risk roles. |
| Allowances | Field Allowance, High Altitude Allowance, and Siachen Allowance. | Risk/Hardship Allowance, Border Duty Allowance. | Army allowances are generally higher due to extreme conditions like Siachen. |
| Post-Retirement Benefits | Reserved quotas in government jobs and housing. | Similar reservations, though less comprehensive. | Army personnel benefit from larger quotas and exclusive schemes. |
| Training Facilities | High-quality training at premier academies like NDA and IMA. | Specialized training for border and counter-insurgency operations. | Army training focuses on conventional warfare, while paramilitary focuses on internal security. |
| Promotions and Career Growth | Structured promotions with greater opportunities. | Promotions depend on vacancies and may be slower. | Army offers faster and more structured career growth. |
| Children’s Scholarships | Scholarships for higher studies through Army Welfare Schemes. | Similar schemes under welfare funds but less extensive. | Army scholarships cover a broader range of options. |
Similarities
- Basic Amenities: Both provide accommodation, education for children, medical care, and canteen facilities.
- Travel Concessions: Both personnel and their families receive subsidized travel.
- Family Welfare: Programs for family well-being, though the extent varies.
- Insurance: Comprehensive life and disability insurance for high-risk duties.
Differences
-
Allowances:
- Army personnel receive higher allowances like Siachen Allowance due to extreme operational conditions.
- Paramilitary personnel get Risk and Hardship Allowance, which is comparatively lower.
-
Retirement Benefits:
- Army has OROP and early retirement options with better pension benefits.
- Paramilitary forces have switched to NPS for recruits after 2004.
-
Training and Career Growth:
- Army training is more extensive, with a focus on combat and strategic operations.
- Paramilitary training is specialized in border security and internal security.
-
Post-Retirement Opportunities:
- Army personnel enjoy better post-retirement opportunities, such as quotas in government jobs and exclusive welfare schemes.
-
CSD Access:
- The Army has a larger and more diverse CSD network, offering greater discounts and goods variety.
Conclusion
The Indian Army enjoys more extensive facilities and benefits due to its critical role in national defense and high-risk operations. Paramilitary forces also receive comprehensive facilities but are tailored more toward their roles in internal security and border management. Both are vital to national security and receive facilities in line with their operational demands.
Follow Us